Thinking Out Loud

September 9, 2016

The Problem of All-or-Nothing Belief in Scripture

Filed under: Christianity — Tags: , — paulthinkingoutloud @ 7:17 am

There’s been a lot of flak online about Andy Stanley’s current sermon series, Who Needs God?* I don’t have time to get into all the various aspects of this, but I wanted to share with you a comment I left at an article by David Prince.  On the other hand, if you want to know where I stand, check out this short article by Thomas L. Horrocks.

Andy Stanley

So you’ve got an 18-year old, first year of college, and they are being bombarded with secular worldviews in general and an attack on the book of Genesis in particular and made to look foolish in the face of questions like, “How can you believe that story of all those animals getting into a large boat?”

It becomes an all-or-nothing proposition and we know statistically, for absolute certainty, that many of these students bail on their faith in that environment. But why should the New Testament gospel narrative suffer because of misgivings about Noah?

I think it is that context into which Andy Stanley is entering. Mostly, it’s uncharted waters. I’ve watched all the messages in the series so far and he is very forthright about what he believes and what he is hoping to accomplish. He stated that it is basically a single 3 1/2 hour sermon, broken up into seven sections, and yes, the first two would be introductory.

Personally, I love what he’s doing with this series. Would NorthPoint be my church if I lived in Atlanta? Maybe not. But through the internet I get a bird’s eye view of what they’re doing, and this sermon series reinvents the wheel when it comes to focusing peoples’ attention on the things that matter, and not making a person’s trust in the Noah story be the litmus test of orthodoxy.

Different? Yes. Radical approach? Certainly. But please don’t call it liberal. That is not the word you’re looking for.

*These are all good, but if time is scarce, scroll down and focus on weeks 3 and 4.

Blog at