Thinking Out Loud

December 30, 2009

Last Link List

…of 2009

  • Trevin Wax at Kingdom People ends the year with The State of the Blogosphere.  I especially like is 5th point on ‘blog congregations’ at the expense of real ‘blog conversations:’  “The people who subscribe to these blogs already know what kind of information they are going to receive. They subscribe because they know and like what this person has to say.
  • Andrew Jones, aka Tall Skinny Kiwi, pronounces the Emerging Church Movement officially dead, but author Tony Jones (no relation) disagrees (again) with TSK’s perspective in this rebuttal.
  • The spiritual autonomy of 1,200 Christian organizations in Canada is under threat as the appeal in the Christian Horizons case continues.   Read this December 29th story in Christian Week for a summary and update.
  • Tullian Tchividjian suggests that The Jesus Storybook Bible, though originally written for children, can help adults understand that “the Bible tells one story and points to one figure: it tells the story of how God rescues a broken world and points to Christ who accomplishes this…” and that the book “…is, in my opinion, one of the best resources available to help both children and adults see the Jesus-centered story line of the Bible.”  Read more at On Earth As It Is Heaven.
  • The link that originally appeared in this space was deleted on January 2nd due to some unforeseen content.
  • The Pew Forum suggests that two-thirds of the world’s population live in countries with some kind of restrictions on religion.
  • Today’s cartoon is a T-shirt available in adult and baby sizes from
  • Don’t forget that here in North America we can reduce the taxes we pay through deduction of charitable donations.   There are many Christian organizations that can use your help.   As of this blog post, you’ve got 30 hours to make a difference to your bottom line for tax purposes, and make a huge difference to a Christian charity or agency.
  • Looking for more?  Use the search window on this blog’s sidebar and type “links” to see some excellent link lists from previous Wednesdays.

May 14, 2009

Will Evangelicalism Go the Way of Mainline Denominations?

Filed under: Christianity, Church, Religion — Tags: , , , , , , , , — paulthinkingoutloud @ 1:39 pm

Much discussion has followed the release of two surveys on Church affiliation in the United States.

The American Religious Identification Survey (ARIS) triggered a reaction by Newsweek magazine, which got a response this week from Christianity Today online.   CT contends that what we’re seeing take place is a shifting from mainline to Evangelical preferences, counter to the Newsweek stance that the survey heralds the end of Christianity in America; something many feel the secular media is dying to announce.

I posted a comment to their article and — for reasons I can’t begin to imagine — the comment wasn’t accepted.    My thesis was and is that many of our so-called “new” denominations, such as the Assemblies of God or the Christian & Missionary Alliance, are actually over 100 years old.  (One C&MA leader used the term ‘geriatric’ about ten years ago.)

The potential “mainlining” of these groups is huge as traditions and modus operandi become entrenched.   But this is not all bad news.   The history of Christianity is a history of new groups and movements continuing to propel the Christian faith through history.    Since each movement is generally a reaction to what preceded it, one would wonder what will be the defining features of the movement which reacts to Evangelicalism.

(There, CT; I said it.   What was so unprintable about that?)

To read the CT article — including a link to the Newsweek piece — and add an unprintable comment of your own,  link here.

The other survey referenced online this week was The Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life  survey entitled Faith in Flux: Changes in Religious Affiliation in the U.S.

I located this story by Michael Bell at the blog Eclectic Christian, which got it via Internet Monk.     You’ve got to read the article, but what caps it off is this graphic depiction of denominational migration.


The article breaks into an extended analysis, but knowing a couple of you aren’t going to link, here’s what you’re seeing in the visuals:

What you are looking at is changes in American adults, from their childhoods to present day. As such it eliminates such factors as birthrate and death rate, and strictly looks at who is changing to what. We should note that immigration is a factor in this chart as present day Americans may have been born elsewhere, and so their childhood would have been in a different country.

Again, when you click the link, you can also click on the graphic and see it full screen (1000 x 600).

Transfer growth is a touchy subject, especially for pastors who are losing parishioners to larger or flashier churches.   But again, the history of Christianity is a history of new movements.

I once heard it said that people migrate from church to church for one of two kinds of reasons:  “push factors” or “pull factors.”   While there are people who feel that someone ‘stepped on their toes;’ I believe most of the migration described here would be of the “pull factor” variety.

Do you attend the church you grew up in?   Have you changed churches in the last 12 months?   What precipitated your change?

Create a free website or blog at