Thinking Out Loud

May 18, 2020

‘Worship Leader’ Should Never Have Been Made a Paid Position

Today we have a guest post in which I agreed to allow the author to remain anonymous. Agree or disagree? Comments are invited. (Where the author responds, it might appear in the comments as a forwarded email under my name.)

The other day, a Facebook user on a worship music user group (there are several out there) posted a rather long-winded, tritely worded and somewhat repetitive rant on how modern worship music songs are getting longer and longer. The writer had, with quite deliberate irony, was illustrating (cleverly, some thought) how it may be a problem. In the rant, they had cited some worship song on YouTube from a prominent ‘song-mill’ that was about 15 minutes in length.

The irony was apparently quite lost on most, as I couldn’t help notice that it wasn’t long after the post that the majority of the post’s readers came at the writer with knives, daggers and claws out! I watched as the comments began to mount, one atop the other, calling him/her out as a ‘Karen’ (slang for a privileged white woman in her middle age who also happens to possess a cheesy bobbed haircut) and slagging him/her for such a negative post.

I think the writer had had enough of the responsive negativity, because when I went to comment, the post had been pulled.

I feel for this person, as I too am a worship leader who has been watching popular Christian worship music shift toward longer and leaner (light on originality and variation) songs, seemingly in attempts to foster a true ‘worship experience’ for attendees, esp. in the larger churches and gatherings. (If you’re reading this in the COVID-19 era ca. 2020, it’s even further irony that none of the above-noted protracted worship services can even be considered or thought of as reasonable for online church services as most social gatherings are suspended or restricted.)

Because ‘the times, they are a changing’ (showing my age much?) my team and I were ‘passed over’ for worship leadership in our former church when the pastor decided to go with this new model, figuring it would attract the younger generation. Hymns and songs older than 10 years? Out. Long ‘basking sessions’ of post-rock style worship with choruses that repeat over and over again til eye-rolling commences in even some of the young in attendance?  In.

But the post questioning the present state of Christian worship music and the visceral reactions from several worship leaders forced me to remember something.

Being a worship leader (particularly in the U.S.) for very many, especially in the very large mega-churches, is a paying gig.

Now I’m well aware that in the New Testament the itinerant or local preacher was paid for his pastoring (and ancient documents like the Didache back that up) but are we supposed to continue in this present millennia with the Jewish traditions of the Levite tribe for that which should really be volunteer work? Didn’t the apostle Paul – a roaming preacher of the Gospel – also have a regular job to cover his expenses to set an example and to never give the church a reason to say, ‘Well, if he weren’t getting paid, he’d not be teaching this newfangled doctrine!’ Yet, he affirmed that the ‘ox shouldn’t be muzzled while treading out the grain’ as well. But worship leaders? Where does it affirm in Scripture that worship leaders are to be paid for their singing/playing songs in a church?

I strongly feel that because many worship leaders are being paid (sometimes ridiculous amounts – I have a chart someone made somewhere that shows their average salaries), they are beholding to their craft, their worth and probably feel impelled to stretch out their song-playing – make the worship ‘experience’ a huge thing in order to justify or validate their salaries or church’s budget.

And maybe this is why Christian music now is so redundant, repetitive and long-winded in character. It was quite interesting to see how some of the folks who blasted the Facebook writer for questioning song-lengths and incessant stanza repetitions ran to Psalm 136, because it clearly shows the repeated phrase ‘His love endures forever’ and which, of course, justifies their 10-20 minute song audience-winder-uppers. The thing is, I can read/recite that particular Psalm in about 2 minutes flat reading aloud at an easy pace!

Another defense tossed about was, “You gotta go with the Spirit. If the Spirit moves, you gotta keep on going.” I am looking for a reference that occurred in the later days of the early church that shows that song-worship went for extended lengths of time. Nope – found nothing. The disciples prayed while awaiting Pentecost. I’m sure they sang songs too, but prayer was the big thing going on and that was BEFORE the Spirit moved on them in a special anointing. Afterward? I see a lot of ministry and amazing signs and wonders at their hands, but no protracted singing sessions, except maybe for Paul and Silas in their jail cell. |(I guess if your hands and legs are bound and you can’t serve the Lord in any other way, you’d be apt to sing a lot too to both praise God in your difficult circumstances and to keep yourself from going mad from the isolation. But it’s worth noting that their songs we’re being heard by their fellow prisoners who were not saved Christians.)

Another justification many Facebook Worship leader group members came up with for their hyper-extended worship songs and praise sessions was, “Well, buddy, you won’t like heaven then – cause you’ll be worshipping God all the time there!”

“Well, okay then”, I would have retorted had I the chance, “let’s work toward not spending more time in service to the suffering and poor or attending to the needs of our families while living on this often demanding earthly plain and just dance before the throne 24/7 right now.” Nope nope… that’s not what worship is. Romans 12:1-2 tells us what real worship is. Songs, hymns and spiritual songs are to be integral to our lives in Christ, but the whole worship scene … tainted by cash-in-hand paid-for-performance worship leaders who have too much invested in their own net worth.

Lastly, with paid worship leaders, another serious issue can arise: the salaried worship leader will oft be inclined to do whatever he or she can to protect his or her gig. When this factor is in play it affords little opportunity for incoming talent from within the local church (or from churches elsewhere) to be utilized in the church for worship leading. The salaried individual holds all the cards, can get possessive or even jealous and feels threatened by abilities that rival his own. And what’s worse, the rival doesn’t want to be a burden to the church by getting paid for their musical offerings. What a racket!

Maybe Luther (if it was him who said it) was right when he said, “The devil fell from heaven and ended up in the choir loft.”

Image sourced uncredited at Worship War Weariness in 2014; the artist may be Dan Nuckols.

Related article: Becky Goes to Church (June 2018)



  1. I tend to agree with the post, although I wouldn’t be so dogmatic- couldn’t music making be a form of tent making?

    Comment by Robert — May 18, 2020 @ 7:50 am

  2. Wow – interesting article Paul! I’d been thinking through a lot of the very same things, but I have to admit Robert’s right – it was maybe a bit dogmatic but definitely too wordy (no offense to the anonymous writer!).

    Though I would like to address Robert’s comment here.

    As songwriters ourselves, we feel that if we write a song and it streams on Spotify (which it has) and/or I get paid by the Canadian outfit for licensed airplay (SOCAN – and which we do), then that is the tent-made remuneration we are due. Playing someone else’s music in church doesn’t seem to fit that scenario, especially. But if the worship team is asked by the pastor or church leaders to create specific content for the church or spends lots of time doing extracurricular things that involve several hours, then some sort of pay would be in order for sure.

    Comment by Liv T.T. — May 18, 2020 @ 4:00 pm

  3. One hour ago Church Curmudgeon posted to Twitter: Just got the new Worship Leader Study Bible. It repeats the last verse of each chapter 7 times.

    Comment by Clark Bunch — May 20, 2020 @ 7:08 pm

    • I saw that. The person(s) who wrote this is (are) on Twitter, so I’m expecting they saw it also.
      It’s been a couple of years now since I figured out who Church Curmudgeon is, and under his real name, he posts some high quality original music.

      Comment by paulthinkingoutloud — May 20, 2020 @ 7:36 pm

  4. Unfortunately a great deal of what was written here also can be applied to other functions which have been made titles in organizations which bear little resemblance to Scripture but nonetheless are referred to as churches. So much of what goes on during the services — and where’s that concept in Scripture? — can be accomplished without the presence of the Spirit, stirring up the feelings etc. just like they used to do at concerts and motivational speaker presentations. We’re planning on assembling tomorrow, this week, there may be praying, praising and preaching, but no paychecks will be issued, out here on the fringe

    Comment by Bryant Vaughn — May 30, 2020 @ 9:37 pm

  5. Found this article after searching for how much worship leaders are paid because I’m a worship leader and I’m not paid and it’s A LOT of work. I think the author and some of the commenters maybe need to take a closer look at the Levites in the Bible. They may not have been paid a salary but they were PROVIDED FOR. They were given land in cities throughout Israel’s tribal allotments and they were fed through the temple sacrifices. Today that might look like giving a worship leader a house and food… but usually it’s just paying them money so they can have a place to live and food to eat and be provided for. And they didn’t just get to eat if they wrote original songs. A lot of the psalms are written by David and a few others, which means the other song leaders probably sang those songs and didn’t always write new ones themselves. I sort of agree about worship songs being long and repetitive BUT again, please see the Bible. The psalms are full of repetitive song lyrics. Check out Psalm 136. Check out Revelation 4:8 which talks about a song that they NEVER STOP SINGING. Maybe the problem is in our own hearts (and eye rolls.)

    Comment by Rachel — July 15, 2021 @ 11:03 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Your Response (Value-Added Comments Only)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: