Thinking Out Loud

May 2, 2016

This Sunday’s “Mother’s Day” is Better as “Women’s Day”

One of the things that struck me when reading Pete Wilson’s book, Plan B, was the many mentions of infertility. I remember thinking, ‘This is a big issue among people in his congregation.’ And maybe for some of you.

With Mother’s Day happening this Sunday in many parts of the world, Russell Moore has written an ever-timely article on infertility. We link to Dr. Moore quite often here, but I don’t know if we had ever committed wholesale theft of one of his blog posts before stealing this one three years ago. But it needed to be seen, and still does. You are encouraged to click through to read it.

Mother’s Day is a particularly sensitive time in many congregations, and pastors and church leaders often don’t even know it. This is true even in congregations that don’t focus the entire service around the event as if it were a feast day on the church’s liturgical calendar. Infertile women, and often their husbands, are still often grieving in the shadows.

Mothers Day and the ChurchIt is good and right to honor mothers. The Bible calls us to do so. Jesus does so with his own mother. We must recognize though that many infertile women find this day almost unbearable. This is not because these women are (necessarily) bitter or covetous or envious. The day is simply a reminder of unfulfilled longings, longings that are good.

Some pastors, commendably, mention in their sermons and prayers on this day those who want to be mothers but who have not had their prayers answered. Some recognize those who are mothers not to children, but to the rest of the congregation as they disciple spiritual daughters in the faith. This is more than a “shout-out” to those who don’t have children. It is a call to the congregation to rejoice in those who “mother” the church with wisdom, and it’s a call to the church to remember those who long desperately to hear “Mama” directed at them.

What if pastors and church leaders were to set aside a day for prayer for children for the infertile?

In too many churches ministry to infertile couples is relegated to support groups that meet in the church basement during the week, under cover of darkness. Now it’s true that infertile couples need each other. The time of prayer and counsel with people in similar circumstances can be helpful.

But this alone can contribute to the sense of isolation and even shame experienced by those hurting in this way. Moreover, if the only time one talks about infertility is in a room with those who are currently infertile, one is probably going to frame the situation in rather hopeless terms.

In fact, almost every congregation is filled with previously infertile people, including lots and lots who were told by medical professionals that they would never have children! Most of those (most of us, I should say) who fit into that category don’t really talk about it much because they simply don’t think of themselves in those terms. The baby or babies are here, and the pain of the infertility has subsided. Infertile couples need to see others who were once where they are, but who have been granted the blessing they seek.

What if, at the end of a service, the pastor called any person or couple who wanted prayer for children to come forward and then asked others in the congregation to gather around them and pray? Not every person grappling with infertility will do this publicly, and that’s all right. But many will. And even those too embarrassed to come forward will be encouraged by a church willing to pray for those hurting this way. The pastor could pray for God’s gift of children for these couples, either through biological procreation or through adoption, whichever the Lord should desire in each case.

Regardless of how you do it, remember the infertile as the world around us celebrates motherhood. The Proverbs 31 woman needs our attention, but the 1 Samuel 1 woman does too.


  1. I have written before on women that for one reason or another dread going to church on Mother’s Day or have in fact quit going on that day. One woman refused to listen to one more sermon, preached by a man, telling her how to be a Proverbs 31 woman. For some it is a reminder of infertility. For others they know the entire service will be about recognizing mothers and handing out awards and what they go to church for is good biblical exegesis.

    I have listened to those concerns and for the most part it would do the church good to respond accordingly. I never like the idea of foregoing an entire church service in lieu of a program that doesn’t begin in scripture and go on to share the Gospel. But we run the risk of taking it too far. My wife and I waited 12 years and suffered through a couple of miscarriages before having a daughter. We grinned and beared more than a few special Mother’s Day services and more than once considered our careers in education (at a private Christian boarding school where we essentially raised other people’s children without being able to have our own). But even then I couldn’t stomach the idea of doing away with Mother’s Day. Even without a child of our own, my wife and I each had mothers of our own that are still with us to this day. Should they not have a special day because we’re to busy whining about our own problems?

    There must be a healthy balance of celebrating and honoring mothers even in light of those that do not have children of their own, have mothers that have passed away or are simply single. Doing away with Mother’s Day (and Father’s Day, and Grandparent’s Day, and not celebrating my kid’s birthday) is akin to giving every kid a trophy. When every kid gets a trophy we fail to recognize actual accomplishment. What mothers do deserves recognition.

    Comment by Clark Bunch — May 2, 2016 @ 8:08 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Your Response (Value-Added Comments Only)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: